If you're shopping for a piece of
in 2017, you're facing compromises. Smartwatches and fitness trackers aren't really the must-have devices many companies hoped they would be. And no, you don't really need one. But if you're looking for a piece of tech for your wrist, here are the best choices right now, followed by a list of what you need to consider.
The best smartwatches and fitness trackers right now
The best smartwatches right now
For the iPhone:
Apple Watch Series 1
(but see below about the
Samsung Gear S3
For most people, The Apple Watch Series 1 is all you'd need. But if you want to swim or use GPS away from your phone, the Series 2 is the one to get. (And note: If you have an original
, there's not a huge need to upgrade to the Series 2 unless you really need that swim-proofing or GPS tracking.) But the Apple Watch wins mainly because it's well hooked-in to iOS, and functions as a great wrist-remote. The Apple Watch isn't perfect by any means, but its feature set is ahead of the competition.
The decision gets harder for Android users.
is the most hooked-in platform that connects to
's apps and services (including Google Assistant), and
Android Wear 2.0
is a big improvement. But there aren't any truly great watches for Android Wear yet.
LG's Watch Sport
, the first to have the updated software, are full of limitations.
The best watch hardware isn't Android Wear at all: it's the Samsung Gear S3.
's large smartwatch has deep features and decent fitness tracking modes, plus use-anywhere Samsung Pay (which requires Android). But it requires a separate set of Samsung Gear apps and syncs to Samsung S-Health for fitness. This requires more conduits and app plug-ins than you might have patience for. It's not as seamless an experience, and sometimes feels too removed from core Android functions.
If you have an Android phone and you're absolutely sold on getting a smartwatch, the Samsung Gear S3 is the best option right now, but that could change once older Android Wear watches are updated to Android Wear 2.0. We're also waiting for Fitbit, Misfit and other companies to release their smartwatches in 2017.
The smartwatches and fitness trackers we can't wait to see in 2017
See all photos
The best fitness trackers
is the right choice for most people. The whole range can track the basics like steps, distance, calories burned and sleep, and some can even measure heart rate and include guided breathing sessions.
One of the reasons we recommend Fitbit is for the app. If one of your friends owns a fitness tracker, there's a good chance it's a Fitbit -- the company has the largest user base. The benefit of this is being able to compete with friends and family members in a variety of competitions, which helps keep you motivated and more likely to reach your goal. The app also integrates a number of third-party devices and services.
For most people, the
Fitbit Charge 2
is the tracker to get. (Note: The just-announced
Fitbit Alta HR
should be considered as well.)
For a more basic (and swim-proof) tracker, we recommend the
Fitbit Flex 2
Looking for a fitness smartwatch? The
is worth a look.
The best non-Fitbit tracker
A reason to skip the Fitbit would be if you're already invested in an ecosystem like Withings or
. In that case, it's best to get one of their trackers.
is our favorite tracker that doesn't look like a tracker.
Garmin Vivosmart HR
(or HR+ for GPS) is our favorite traditional Garmin fitness tracker.
Withings Steel HR
is our favorite Withings tracker.
The best GPS watches
Athletes and outdoor enthusiasts are better off with a GPS watch to accurately measure pace, distance, speed and other metrics.
For casual and serious runners, our favorite is the
Garmin Forerunner 235
$167 at Amazon
For casual multisport athletes it's the
Garmin Vivoactive HR
Serious triathletes should check out the
For the ultimate multisport and outdoor watch, there's the
Garmin Fenix 3 HR
, but it will soon be replaced by the newly announced
All of these watches are waterproof down to at least 50 meters, include multiple sport profiles, can track daily fitness metrics like steps, sleep and heart rate, and can display notifications from an iPhone and Android phone.
The best GPS bike computers
Cyclists should consider a GPS bike computer for measuring distance and speed. These devices can also connect with other sensors on your bike to measure additional metrics like cadence and power.
For beginners, we recommend the
More serious riders should check out the
Garmin Edge 520
Shopping for wearables: What you need to know
The wearable market is getting smaller.
Fitbit bought Pebble
, Jawbone has pivoted away from consumer trackers, and other companies (such as Motorola) have
put their smartwatch plans on hold
. But there's still a wide variety of smartwatches and trackers to choose from. Here's how to find the right one.
Android or iPhone?
That still matters, to a degree. The Apple Watch works with iPhones -- and only iPhones. Android
work with Android Wear. Samsung's Gear S2 and S3 watches work with Android phones, too. Both Android Wear and Samsung watches pair with iPhones, but in a more limited way that is nowhere as good as what the Apple Watch offers. Fitness bands tend to work cross-platform, but not always.
Does charging a watch annoy you?
Many premium smartwatches still have battery life of two days or less between charges. The Apple Watch, Google's Android Wear watches, and Samsung's Gear S2 and S3 are high-maintenance, and need daily or every-other-day charging. Are you ready to live with that?
If so, the Apple Watch, Samsung Gear S3 or an updated Android Wear 2.0 watch might be worth a try. Pebble's long-battery smartwatches still exist, but Pebble's sale to Fitbit and Pebble's uncertain watch future as a platform means we don't recommend current models anymore.
Do you want a great fitness tracker?
Most wearable bands and watches aim for fitness tracking, but some are better than others. The best pure overall fitness tracker is still the Fitbit Charge 2. Garmin also makes several good alternatives, and good running watches.
Full-featured smartwatches like the Apple Watch and Android Wear 2.0 watches can track activities and work with many third-party fitness apps, but connect mainly to
Health and Google Fit for synced data.
Is it rude to buy someone a fitness tracker as a gift?
Do you want to swim with it?
Many wearables are water resistant to at least wash-your-hands or quick-dunk-in-a-sink level, but the list of real swim-proof trackers and watches is short. You want to look for 3ATM or 5ATM, or anything that suggests meters of water resistance.
The Apple Watch Series 2, Fitbit Flex 2, Withings Steel HR, Misfit Ray, Garmin Vivoactive HR and Garmin Forerunner 235 are some of our favorite swim-friendly wearables. The Pebble 2, Pebble Time and Time Steel are swim-friendly, too. But they don't all do swim tracking.
For swim tracking, look into the Garmin Vivoactive HR, Garmin Fenix 3 HR, Garmin Forerunner 735XT, Apple Watch Series 2, Misfit Ray, Withings Steel HR and Fitbit Flex 2.
Watches with built-in phones aren't great, but they exist
Some smartwatches come with phone service inside. The Samsung Gear S3 Frontier, LG Watch Sport and
work with SIM cards and can function as independent phones. Samsung and
's watches work with T-Mobile and AT&T, while Verizon's Wear24 is, well, Verizon. Phone service can be useful in case of emergency, but it drains battery life on the watch and requires an extra monthly payment (currently $5 a month on T-Mobile, $10 a month on AT&T) to use. AT&T allows phone-number syncing across devices.
You can pay for things with your watch
Lots of smartwatches support mobile payments now. They mostly work the same way. Apple Watches have Apple Pay. Samsung's Gear S2 and S3 watches can use Samsung Pay. It adds an extra wrinkle on the S3 model with MST, a technology that works at regular credit card terminals as well as tap-to-pay ones. Android Wear 2.0-updated watches will work with Android Pay as long as the watch has NFC. Not all Android Wear watches do. Right now, in fact, the only Android Pay-enabled watch is the LG Watch Sport.